Eastern Division

 

 

1.800.440.4556

 

 
Printable Page Headline News   Return to Menu - Page 1 2 3 5 6 7 8 13
 
 
SCOTUS Blocks NY Worship Virus Limits  11/27 06:31

   

   WASHINGTON (AP) -- With coronavirus cases surging again nationwide, the 
Supreme Court barred New York from enforcing certain limits on attendance at 
churches and synagogues in areas designated as hard hit by the virus.

   The justices split 5-4 late Wednesday night, with new Justice Amy Coney 
Barrett in the majority. It was the conservative's first publicly discernible 
vote as a justice. The court's three liberal justices and Chief Justice John 
Roberts dissented.

   The move was a shift for the court. Earlier this year, when Barrett's 
liberal predecessor, Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, was still on the court, the 
justices divided 5-4 to leave in place pandemic-related capacity restrictions 
affecting churches in California and Nevada.

   The court's action Wednesday could push New York to reevaluate its 
restrictions on houses of worship in areas designated virus hot spots. But the 
impact is also muted because the Catholic and Orthodox Jewish groups that sued 
to challenge the restrictions are no longer subject to them.

   New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo, a Democrat, said Thursday the ruling was "more 
illustrative of the Supreme Court than anything else" and "irrelevant from any 
practical impact" given that the restrictions have already been removed.

   "Why rule on a case that is moot and come up with a different decision than 
you did several months ago on the same issue?" Cuomo asked in a conference call 
with reporters. "You have a different court. And I think that was the statement 
that the court was making."

   The Diocese of Brooklyn and Agudath Israel of America have churches and 
synagogues in areas of Brooklyn and Queens previously designated red and orange 
zones. In those red and orange zones, the state had capped attendance at houses 
of worship at 10 and 25 people, respectively. But the those particular areas 
are now designated as yellow zones with less restrictive rules neither group 
challenged.

   The justices acted on an emergency basis, temporarily barring New York from 
enforcing the restrictions against the groups while their lawsuits continue. In 
an unsigned opinion the court said the restrictions "single out houses of 
worship for especially harsh treatment."

   "Members of this Court are not public health experts, and we should respect 
the judgment of those with special expertise and responsibility in this area. 
But even in a pandemic, the Constitution cannot be put away and forgotten. The 
restrictions at issue here, by effectively barring many from attending 
religious services, strike at the very heart of the First Amendment's guarantee 
of religious liberty," the opinion said.

   The opinion noted that in red zones, while a synagogue or church cannot 
admit more than 10 people, businesses deemed "essential," from grocery stores 
to pet shops, can remain open without capacity limits. And in orange zones, 
while synagogues and churches are capped at 25 people, "even non-essential 
businesses may decide for themselves how many persons to admit."

   Roberts, in dissent, wrote that there was "simply no need" for the court's 
action. "None of the houses of worship identified in the applications is now 
subject to any fixed numerical restrictions," he said, adding that New York's 
10 and 25 person caps "do seem unduly restrictive."

   "The Governor might reinstate the restrictions. But he also might not. And 
it is a significant matter to override determinations made by public health 
officials concerning what is necessary for public safety in the midst of a 
deadly pandemic," he wrote.

   Roberts and four other justices wrote separately to explain their views. 
Barrett did not.

   The court's action was a victory for the Roman Catholic Church and Orthodox 
Jewish synagogues that had sued to challenge state restrictions announced by 
Cuomo on Oct. 6.

   The Diocese of Brooklyn, which covers Brooklyn and Queens, argued houses of 
worship were being unfairly singled out by the governor's executive order. The 
diocese argued it had previously operated safely by capping attendance at 25% 
of a building's capacity and taking other measures. Parts of Brooklyn and 
Queens are now in yellow zones where attendance at houses of worship is capped 
at 50% of a building's capacity, but the church is keeping attendance lower.

   "We are extremely grateful that the Supreme Court has acted so swiftly and 
decisively to protect one of our most fundamental constitutional rights --- the 
free exercise of religion," said Randy Mastro, an attorney for the diocese, in 
a statement.

   Avi Schick, an attorney for Agudath Israel of America, wrote in an email: 
"This is an historic victory. This landmark decision will ensure that religious 
practices and religious institutions will be protected from government edicts 
that do not treat religion with the respect demanded by the Constitution."

   Two lower courts had sided with New York in allowing the restrictions to 
remain in place. New York had argued that religious gatherings were being 
treated less restrictively than secular gatherings that carried the same 
infection risk, like concerts and theatrical performances.

   There are currently several areas in New York designated orange zones but no 
red zones, according to a state website that tracks areas designated as hot 
spots.

 
 
Copyright DTN. All rights reserved. Disclaimer.
hi
Powered By DTN